Italian MEP Compares Foibe to Nazi Concentration Camps

Strasbourg, 13 April

The recent stirring of old differences between World War II foes Italy and Slovenia has moved to the European Parliament, where an Italian MP called for "the forgotten and denied" story about foibe to be laid bare. This prompted a response from a Slovenian MEP, who said Italy was using the story as an alibi for its own war crimes.

According to Cristiana Muscardini, a member of Italy's far-right National Alliance and the Union for European Nations, the story of the Italians killed by Yugoslav partisan forces and thrown into foibe, Karst pits, is one of the first cases of ethnic cleansing in Europe in the 20th century.
Between 3,000 and 20,000 Italians were killed and thrown into foibe only because they were Italians, Muscardini claimed during today's session of the European Parliament. She added that many people still mistakenly believe that those thrown into foibe were victims of Nazi violence.
It is only right that the real story be told and that we recognise the atrocities of communism, Muscardini said, adding that the foibe rate right up there with Nazi concentration camps on a scale of the most horrific war crimes.
Muscardini's comments have prompted a response from Slovenian MEP Mojca Drcar Murko, a member of the European Liberals, who said in a press statement that Italy was trying to change history with its claim that it was the victim of expansionist Slav policies.
Murko claims that Yugoslav forces had killed around 300 high-ranking Fascist officials in 1943 and that there were cases of reprisals against Italians in Istria by the local population.
The claims of ethnic cleansing of Italians were first made by Nazi forces which occupied the territories after Italy's withdrawal in 1943, Murko says.
Italy has never allowed a proper investigation into the foibe, she adds. Instead, it has been happy to use the foibe as an instrument for ideological attacks against the former Yugoslavia and as an alibi for Italian war crimes.
According to Murko, the events that took place in Istria must be consider keeping in mind the circumstances of the time and considering all facts.
Old hatreds between Italy and Slovenia were dug up recently by a controversial Italian film and a national holiday in Italy to remember Italians who left the former Yugoslav territories after WWII.
The film in the centre of the controversy, "Il cuore nel pozzo" (The Heart in a Pit), tells a story of the summary executions in the 1940s of Italian civilians by the Yugoslav partisans.
Despite the claims of the film's creators that it is a work of art, the film has become highly politicised. In Italy, the National Alliance, which has its roots in Mussolini's Fascist party, has virtually become its sponsor.
In Slovenia and Croatia the film has been branded as an attempt to depict the partisans as the aggressors of WWII.
Slovenian veteran groups have decried the film, calling it an attempt to change history.

More articles from this issue:

Politics
PM Confident About Development Potential of SW Region
Koper, 13 April
Foreign Policy
Italian MEP Compares Foibe to Nazi Concentration Camps
Strasbourg, 13 April
Bilateral Relations
Drnovsek and Kwasniewski for Ratification of EU Constitution
Warsaw, 13 April
Government
Contested Bill on Public Broadcaster Ready for Parliament
Ljubljana, 14 April
Government Amends Three WWII-Related Acts, Veterans Protest
Ljubljana, 14 April
Govt Adopts Zoning Act for Koper-Divaca Railway
Ljubljana, 14 April
Parliament
Spring Day in Europe: Slovenian Pupils on EU Constitution
Ljubljana, 13 April
Economy
Companies Share Experience in Entering New Markets
Ljubljana, 18 April
Adria Carries 885,000 Passengers, Ends 2004 With Profit
Brnik, 13 April
IMF Forecasts 4% Growth for Slovenia This Year
Washington, 13 April
Slovenia Well Prepared to Adopt Euro, Central Bank Says
Portoroz, 13 April
Companies Feel Consequences of EU Trade Policy
Ljubljana, 16 April
Adria Mobil Sees Rapid Growth in 2004
Novo mesto, 13 April
Agriculture
WFP Delegation Expected in Ljubljana
Ljubljana, 19 April
Technology
Slovenia in Favour of R&D Programme, Says Minister
Luxembourg, 18 April
EU Topics
Interregional Cooperation Helping overcome Challenges in the EU
Bled, 14 April
Vizjak Highlights Economic Benefits of EU Accession
Vienna, 14 April
Transport
Adria to Fly Officials to Brussels until October
Ljubljana, 12 April
Culture
Open-Air Book Fair Opens in Ljubljana
Ljubljana, 18 April
"Ruins" Gets First Award Abroad
Bari, 13 April
Dance, Theatre, Hip Hop and Discourse at 11th Exodos Festival
Ljubljana, 15 April
People
Slovenia Boasts Highest Employment Rate for Women with Children
Luxembourg, 12 April
NUK Puts on Exhibition on Author Alma Karlin
Ljubljana, 14 April
Extreme Cyclist Encircles Slovenia in Record 46 Hours
Ljubljana, 17 April
Calendar of Events
Schedule of Events

Archive

year month
2008 1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   11   12
2007 1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   11   12
2006 1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   11   12
2005 1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   11   12
2004 1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   11   12